The exemption deadline has passed, a Staten Island judge ordered the city to redo its rollout, an appeals court put that order on hold, and a decision is expected by November 10. Here's the full picture as of October 28, 2026.
By Pete Weinman, Esq.
As of October 28, 2026: The exemption application deadline passed on October 13, 2026. On September 29, Staten Island Supreme Court Justice Wayne Ozzi ordered the city to redo its rollout. Around October 6, the Appellate Division, Second Department put that order on hold; a decision is expected by November 10, 2026. The surcharge remains in place and the city continues to administer it. Property tax bills including the surcharge are expected January 1, 2027 (reported; verify with NYC Department of Finance). See the original guide for background.
What's New Since September 9
A lot has happened in the seven weeks since I first published this post. Here is the short version, in order.
The exemption deadline was extended again — and has now passed. The city extended the application deadline a third time, to October 13, 2026. That date has passed. If you applied, you should have a confirmation. If you missed the deadline, do not assume you are out of luck and do not assume you are safe — contact the NYC Department of Finance directly and ask what options, if any, remain open. No outcome can be promised.
Justice Ozzi ruled on September 29 that the city must redo its rollout. Staten Island Supreme Court Justice Wayne Ozzi ruled that the city failed to adequately analyze who should be taxed and improperly placed the burden on homeowners to prove their own residency. His ruling challenged the rollout — the published list and the exemption process — not the legality of the tax itself. The tax remains on the books.
The Appellate Division, Second Department put that ruling on hold around October 6. The appeals court in Brooklyn stayed Justice Ozzi's order while the appeal is pending. A decision is expected by November 10, 2026. The city continues to administer the surcharge in the meantime.
More than 6,800 exemptions were granted from more than 11,000 applications. Reporting from around October 16 (Habitat magazine, citing Crain's) put the exemption count at more than 6,800 from more than 11,000 applications submitted, out of roughly 17,000 notices originally mailed in July. If you applied and received a confirmation of exemption, keep that document permanently with your property records.
Separate constitutional lawsuits are pending. Separate litigation — including a lawsuit reported to be brought by Wilbur Ross and Steve Wynn — argues the surcharge is unconstitutional because it singles out nonresidents. Those cases are pending and unresolved.
Bills are expected January 1, 2027. The city plans to add the surcharge to property tax bills due January 1, 2027 (reported; confirm with NYC Department of Finance).
What Stays the Same
The surcharge itself has not been repealed or suspended. The Appellate Division's stay means Justice Ozzi's order is on hold, not that the rollout has been validated. The city is still administering the program.
Coverage is one-, two-, and three-family homes valued at $5 million or more, and co-ops and condos valued at $1 million or more. Being on the city's list is not the same as owing the surcharge — eligibility depends on property type, value, primary-residence status, applicable exemptions, and the Department of Finance process.
Official links: NYC Non-Primary Residence Surcharge | NYC Property Assessments
What to Do Now
If you applied and received an exemption confirmation: Keep that document permanently with your property records. If you later receive a bill that appears to include the surcharge, contact the Department of Finance immediately with your confirmation in hand.
If you applied and your exemption was denied: Keep the denial letter. Ask the Department of Finance about the review or appeal process and its time limit. Verify any deadline directly with the Department before relying on it.
If you missed the October 13 deadline: Contact the Department of Finance now and ask what options exist. Do not assume you are automatically exempt and do not assume you are automatically liable. No outcome can be promised.
If you received a retraction letter saying you are exempt: Keep it permanently with your property records.
If you are buying or selling a covered property: Liability attaches to the property. Your attorney should check for surcharge exposure during title and closing — and for co-ops, should check what the board requires. This is general information, not legal advice.
Background: How We Got Here
The surcharge took effect May 28, 2026. The Department of Finance published a supplemental market-value roll on July 24, 2026, listing roughly 17,000 properties. The city did not have access to New York State's 2025 income tax filings when it compiled that initial list, which is why a significant number of full-time primary residents were included in error. The city subsequently sent retraction letters to homeowners it determined were primary residents, and the exemption application process ran through October 13.
In August, a class-action style lawsuit was filed in Staten Island Supreme Court challenging the rollout. A temporary restraining order was issued, and the city's searchable online database was taken down. That TRO was later lifted on appeal, and the city resumed administering the program. Justice Ozzi's September 29 ruling went further than the TRO — he ordered the city to redo the rollout entirely — but the Appellate Division has now put that order on hold pending appeal.
The October 6 deadline mentioned in earlier versions of this post was an earlier deadline that was subsequently extended. It is no longer operative.
The Takeaway: Still in Motion
This situation will not be fully resolved until the Appellate Division rules — expected by November 10, 2026 — and possibly not until the January 2027 bills go out and any resulting disputes are addressed. I will update this post when the appeals court issues its decision and again when the January 2027 bills are sent.
What I can tell you right now: the surcharge is still in place, the city is still administering it, and the legal fight is not over. If your property is in the covered categories — one-, two-, or three-family homes at $5 million or more, or co-ops and condos at $1 million or more — stay engaged with this.
Related Articles
Related Articles
Fossella Rallies at Midland Beach as NYC Extends the Pied-à-Terre Exemption Deadline
Staten Island's Borough President led a public rally at Midland Beach against NYC's non-primary resi…
Why Some Staten Island Homeowners Just Got a Letter About NYC's New Non-Primary Residence Property Surcharge
Staten Island names are on NYC's non-primary residence property surcharge roll — but most don't owe …
Wall Street Investors Just Got Boxed Out Twice — What It Means for Staten Island Sellers
New York limited institutional investors buying single-family homes. Now a federal law does too. Pet…